BOROCHAT

England 2004 v 2024

By Sev11/7 13:45Thu Jul 11 13:45:06 2024

Views: 925

Just saw Harry Redknapp picking between the two sets of players and basically choosing all 2004 ones bar a couple, which goes to show how well Southgate has done to get the best out of this group. You try:

Pickford or David James

Trippier or Ashley Cole
Guehi or Sol Campbell
Stones or John Terry
Walker or Gary Neville

Bellingham or Lampard
Rice or Gerrard
Mainoo or Scholes
Saka or Beckham
Foden or Rooney
Kane or Owen

Edited by Sev at 13:46:54 on 11th July 2024

reply to this article | return to the front page

Re: England 2004 v 2024

By Owen B11/7 15:28Thu Jul 11 15:28:05 2024In response to England 2004 v 2024Top of thread

Views: 817

Pickford or David James

Trippier or Ashley Cole
Guehi or Sol Campbell
Stones or John Terry
Walker or Gary Neville

Bellingham or Lampard
Rice or Gerrard
Mainoo or Scholes
Saka or Beckham
Foden or Rooney
Kane or Owen

Edited by Owen B at 15:28:34 on 11th July 2024

reply to this article | return to the front page

1 person

Re: England 2004 v 2024

By Phoenix11/7 14:14Thu Jul 11 14:14:18 2024In response to England 2004 v 2024Top of thread

Views: 805

2024 shades it for me...

Pickford or David James - Pickford

Trippier or Ashley Cole - Cole
Guehi or Sol Campbell - Campbell
Stones or John Terry - Stones
Walker or Gary Neville - Walker

Bellingham or Lampard - Bellingham
Rice or Gerrard - Gerrard
Mainoo or Scholes - Scholes
Saka or Beckham - Saka
Foden or Rooney - Rooney
Kane or Owen - Kane

reply to this article | return to the front page

Re: England 2004 v 2024

By Freemo11/7 14:34Thu Jul 11 14:34:42 2024In response to Re: England 2004 v 2024Top of thread

Views: 809

Pickford
Cole
Campbell
Terry
Walker
Lampard
Gerrard
Scholes
Saka
Rooney
Kane

So 7 from 2004 and 4 from 2024. It's tricky though because for example in reality Declan Rice is a far better player for England than Gerrard or Lampard were despite having more to their game.

reply to this article | return to the front page

Re: England 2004 v 2024

By Sev11/7 18:32Thu Jul 11 18:32:33 2024In response to Re: England 2004 v 2024Top of thread

Views: 696

Yeah I think you're meant to do it based on individuals at their peak who is the better player, not how well they do in an England shirt/team.

Edited by Sev at 18:32:38 on 11th July 2024

reply to this article | return to the front page

Re: England 2004 v 2024

By Freemo11/7 20:29Thu Jul 11 20:29:30 2024In response to Re: England 2004 v 2024Top of thread

Views: 662

Also whilst I don't think Neville gets there for the last ditch tackle, he could have put in a proper cross on one of the numerous occasions Walker didn't.

reply to this article | return to the front page

1 person